SELL US YOUR SLABSYOUR GRADED COLLECTION. YOUR NEXT MOVE.
TURN YOUR
PSA SLABS
INTO CASH.
Get a quote, ship free, and get paid after verification by a real card shop you can trust.
START YOUR QUOTE How it works ↓REAL SHOP.
REAL PEOPLE.
YOUR PSA COLLECTION
BUILD YOUR
CASH OFFER.
Enter the PSA certification number on your slab. Add each slab to see your estimated cash offer from PENNY.
Your quote lists each slab and its offer. You can remove a slab before accepting.
01 ADD YOUR SLABS
02 CHOOSE DELIVERY & PAYMENT
03 SAVE YOUR QUOTE
YOUR QUOTE
What slabs are you selling?
Your slabs will appear here. Start with a PSA cert number above.
Non-binding estimate only. Final purchase is subject to physical verification of each slab.
FROM YOUR COLLECTION TO OUR SHOP
HOW IT WORKS.
- 01
QUOTE.
Add your PSA cert numbers and review your cash offer. Choose how you’ll deliver your slabs and receive payment.
- 02
PACK.
Mailing your slabs? Print your two-page document. Put the packing slip inside your box and the prepaid USPS label outside.
- 03
GET PAID.
Ship your protected slabs or drop them off at Izzi’s Gym. Payment follows physical verification.
SHIP OR DROP OFF HERE
Izzi’s Gym
808 N West Ave
Sioux Falls, SD 57104
REAL SHOP. REAL PEOPLE.
YOUR SLABS.
IN GOOD HANDS.
Your slabs are going to a physical card shop, not a P.O. box.
Izzi’s Gym is the largest TCG card shop in the Upper Midwest.
READ OUR GOOGLE REVIEWS ↗WHY SELLERS FEEL SAFE SENDING TO IZZI'S GYM
BEFORE YOU SEND IT
COMMON
QUESTIONS.
Everything you need to get started with your PSA slabs.
Call 605.937.2766What slabs can I get a quote for?
Enter a PSA certification number to request an offer from PENNY. If a slab needs manual review, you’ll see that in your quote and won’t be able to accept it until reviewed.
Is my offer final?
No. Your quote is a non-binding estimate. Izzi’s Gym must physically verify each slab’s authenticity, certification, condition, and submitted information. We may correct errors, revise, or withdraw a quote before completing a purchase or payment.
How does shipping work?
After accepting a mail-in quote, download your two-page shipping document. The packing slip goes inside the box and the prepaid USPS label goes outside. Shipping uses USPS Ground Advantage with insurance and signature confirmation.
Can I drop off my slabs?
Yes. Choose “Drop off at Izzi’s Gym” when entering your details, then bring your slabs to 808 N West Ave, Sioux Falls, SD 57104. No shipping label is needed.
When and how do I get paid?
Payment follows physical verification. For mail-in quotes, choose a mailed check, Venmo, Cash App, Zelle, or PayPal when entering your details.